Reflect on the idea that tests are the only objective assessment of student learning.
My immediate reaction to this statement is, "Definitely not!" When recalling the different types of assessment that I use in my class, I typically use of variety of assessment tools in order to keep the students engaged and to diversify my teaching style. However, in order for any assessment to be objective, there needs to be some type of rubric by which to measure. For example, when I taught World History, I developed a cumulative project for the French Revolution unit. The project was titled "A Day in the Life of the French Revolution." In groups, students created either a movie or a storyboard (with photos of the students) re-creating one of the most significant days during the French Revolution. Each group selected a different day and/or event to re-enact, and each student also had to write two two-page reflections speaking in first person as if they witnessed the event. This project allowed students to be creative and artistic; however, there was a very detailed rubric outlining how points would be added or deducted. Because each group selected a different event, I had to develop a way in which to objectively compare each group's work. The rubric allowed me to do just this. Rubrics are a means of objectively evaluating subjective work.
Other forms of assessment that I have used to objectively judge student progress include creating a colonial newspaper during my U.S. History Colonial Period unit. Students work together to create a newspaper recounting different events from the colonial period. Each newspaper turns out completely different and unique; however, each is assessed using the same rubric. Just as with the French Revolution project, the rubric details the breakdown of the grade. 50 points of the grade reflects each student's individual work (written reflections/reports), and the other 50 points is the group score, which is same for all groups members. I use this strategy to ensure that one group members will not complete the entire project, and all other members get the same credit. It has been successful so far.
In my Introduction to Sociology class, students create projects entitled "The Evolution of Culture." In this project, students create an iMovie or a Power Point presentation that reveals answers from interviews with people examining how culture has changed and evolved over time. I evaluate the students on their individual performance, as well as the group work. A detailed rubric is essential to make this an objective assessment. If students wonder why they lost points on a test they understand it is because they answered a question incorrectly. If students lose points in a group project, they can look on their rubric and see exactly why points were deducted.
Obviously, rubrics are essential to make any non-test assessment objective. I believe that any student work can be made objective by the use of a rubric. Students enjoy doing group and individual projects, because they appeal to different learning modalities. As a teacher, I enjoy watching my students succeed in different areas, which requires me to adapt specific rubrics in order to make it objective.
No comments:
Post a Comment